A louder Big House
Prof's test says skyboxes will increase noise level at games
- Page 1 of 1
|
The addition of luxury boxes to Michigan Stadium will make it louder, according to tests by a University professor.
During halftime at Saturday's football game against Minnesota, Mojtaba Navvab, an associate architecture professor, and other researchers measured sound in Michigan Stadium at the 50-yard line to predict what impact the planned renovations will have in making the stadium louder.
Sound often evaporates into the air at The Big House, which has a reputation for being a relatively quiet stadium despite touting the nation's largest crowds. Because there aren't many things for the crowd noise to reflect off of, the oval-shaped bowl loses sound.
The skyboxes would amplify the sounds of the crowd by further enclosing the stadium, causing sound to bounce back onto the field instead of escaping.
In a press conference in September, Penn State wideout Deon Butler said the noise and intimidation factor at The Big House were low for a stadium of its size.
"It's not a super-overwhelming place," he said. "Yes, it's large, and they're supposed to have more people than us, but it's not overwhelming in the sense that it's not as tense as Beaver Stadium. Their fans aren't near as rowdy as our fans."
When Navvab and his team took measurements during Saturday's halftime, they found that the sound - almost exclusively from the student section - was 100 decibels, or the equivalent of a chainsaw.
With the skyboxes, which will stand about 10 feet higher than the scoreboards and further enclose the stadium, the sound level of the stadium would reach 110 or 111 decibels, about the noise level of a loud rock concert, Navvab said.
In order to measure how much of an impact the skyboxes would have on sound in the stadium, Navvab used a sensor that measures sound from all angles at the same time.
The sensor consists of 120 small microphones that absorb every decibel within hundreds of feet. The device can pinpoint exactly how much sound individual people and instruments make in a crowd of thousands.
Navvab and his team then took what each individual microphone measured, compiled it and used a computer program to translate the measurements into architectural graphics that allow the researchers to see exactly where the sound is located and where it is loudest.
During the game, Navvab and his team measured crowd noise levels from various points along the sidelines.
There were other factors that Navvab had to take into account when measuring, such as the duration of the yells from the crowd.
Navvab used the sensor to measure how long it took the crowd to reach "full loudness," the point at which the noise intensity level remains steady.
Crowd participation was almost entirely located in the student section. If all 109,840 individuals had yelled at the same intensity, Navvab said the measurement would have increased to 102 or 103 decibels - a significant sound increase.
The loud noise from the crowd can drown out the sound of the opposing quarterback giving instructions to his players on the field - giving the home team a significant advantage.
Viewing Comments 1 - 8 of 9
Andrew
posted 11/01/07 @ 10:23 AM EST
This whole test might have been worth it if people had actually been filling the seats. When the test was going on, a good number of seats were empty as people filed out to the concourse. (Continued…)
Ben
posted 11/01/07 @ 11:21 AM EST
I am not a statistician, but basing conclusions on a single test seems like a recipe for error. This test seems like something that should have been performed at every game all season long, especially if you're going to use it to support the case for building luxury boxes. (Continued…)
Alex Makris
posted 11/01/07 @ 11:41 AM EST
Professor,
I cannot question your acumen within the domain of architecture design. I want to point out a factor that may not have entered into your calculation of a louder stadium, however: enthusiasm. (Continued…)
Student
posted 11/01/07 @ 12:16 PM EST
The noise was coming almost exclusively from the student section.
Maybe if they want the Big House to be louder, they should get those alumni to cheer louder and act like they did when they were students. (Continued…)
Aaron
posted 11/01/07 @ 1:39 PM EST
i think some of the questioning of the results of this test by previous posters is wrong. the conclusion that the professor made is that in the presence of the luxury boxes, the sound level at midfield will be louder because the sound will no escape as easily assuming no change in voice level. (Continued…)
Tim
posted 11/01/07 @ 7:21 PM EST
I attended this game. I'm not a student. Nobody around us knew what was going on. I asked our son (who is a student) after the game if he knew what was happening. (Continued…)
cutter
posted 11/01/07 @ 7:29 PM EST
I hate to break it to you, but anyone thinking that seating at Michigan Stadium is egalitarian in the present day is patentedly wrong and entirely utopian. (Continued…)


cmadler
posted 11/01/07 @ 8:35 AM EST
This seems like a lame attempt to justify an unpopular change. Sure skyboxes would increase the decibel level on the field. Adding a full upper tier of seats to the stadium would increase the decibel level even more. (Continued…)